Table of Contents
Share

BroThrow

VIP/Rewards Grade: 1/5
Summary: BroThrow is a Peer-to-Peer marketplace where you can bet directly against others. BroThrow is unique in that all bets are settled outside of BroThrow via third party payment providers like Venmo.

Updated: Oct 27, 2025
4 min read

Note: If you are located in Ontario, we are not able to display any available promotions.

Matched Betting

What is the "Matched Betting Value" listed above? This is the amount of profit that you can make from the sign-up offer through a technique called matched betting. In short, it is a mathematical approach to sports betting that guarantees profit by hedging your bets. This allows you to cover all possible outcomes and secure a profit no matter what happens in the game. This is different from gambling because there is no risk of losing. Learn more in our What Is Matched Betting guide.

{{cta="/components"}}

What To Know

BroThrow is regulated by your local gaming commission. Regulated sportsbooks provide customer protections that you will not have when using an unregulated sportsbooks or sweepstakes sportsbooks.
BroThrow is unregulated. Unregulated sportsbooks do not provide the same customer proctections that regulated sportsbooks have.
BroThrow is CFTC-Regulated. CFTC-regulated platforms are federally regulated futures markets, which offer different protections than sportsbooks regulated by a state gaming commission.
BroThrow follows a sweepstakes model. Sweepstakes platforms are regulated by the Federal Trade Commission and state sweepstakes laws instead of your jurisdiction's gaming commisison. These protections are less than those provided by a regulated sportsbook, and are designed for traditional sweepstakes, not a sportsbook.
BroThrow is a sportsbook. Sportsbooks, unlike exchanges, act as "The House" and often have more vig than a betting exchange.
BroThrow is an exchange. Exchanges often offer better odds than a traditional sportsbook, do not limit players, and are matched betting friendly.
BroThrow is a P2P/Marketplace. P2P/Marketplace betting platforms often operate like a Betting Exchange. There might be minor differences, such as commission and fee structure.
BroThrow is an Prediction Market. Prediction markets work like a stock market, but instead of trading shares, you’re buying and selling contracts based on future events, from sports to weather to elections.
In some states BroThrow operates as a betting exchange, and others they operate as a sportsbook. In both situations BroThrow will not limit bettors.
BroThrow is "Player Friendly". Player friendly sportsbooks/exchanges do not enact limits on players making them perfect for matched betting.
BroThrow is "Slower-to-Limit". Slower-to-Limit sportsbooks take longer than average to enact limits on winning bettors.
BroThrow is "Quick-to-Limit". Quick-to-Limit sportsbooks enact limits signifcantly faster than your average sportsbook. If you show signs of being a winning bettor, limits will quickly follow.
BroThrow has high limits. Sportsbooks with higher limits are useful for generating VIP status and hedging large promotions.
BroThrow has low limits. Sportsbooks with lower limits are can make hedging larger promootions, such as those assocaited with VIP status, difficult.
BroThrow seems to be more likely than other sportsbooks to limit bettors after a withdraw. Avoid withdraws from BroThrow as much as possible.
Incremental withdrawals of $2,500 or less once a week seem less likely to results in limits on BroThrow.

Available Locations

BroThrow is available in the following locations.

Overview

Founded in 2019, BroThrow is a free Peer-to-Peer sports betting platform where bettors compete directly against other bettors instead of against “The House.” Rather than charging fees on every bet you make, BroThrow earns revenue if you choose to subscribe to PRO features. BroThrow provides the marketplace where bettors create, accept, and track bets directly with other ID-verified bettors. BroThrow bettors settle up directly with each other via integrations with popular payment apps like Venmo, PayPal, and Cash App.

Before signing up for BroThrow, there a few things you should know.

  • All bets are settled outside of BroThrow through payment apps like Venmo.
  • There is a dispute process if you do not get paid, and users who do not settle bets get banned.
  • There is no commission.
  • To increase your betting limits, there is a subscription fee.

Since payments are settled outside of BroThrow, the biggest challenge is staying organized. The easiest way to do this is to only send/request payments once a day. If you send and request all required payments each morning for the previous day, tracking what you owe/are owed is much easier.

BroThrow Basics

Create an account and use code "DARKHORSE" to get a $10 Second Chance Bet, BroThrow calls it a Free Bet. Once you create an account, you can select your subscription level. Go to Account -> Subscription.

Free

  • No Cost
  • $50 Daily limit
  • Create Groups, add friends
  • Bet publicly and privately

Pro

  • $25 a month
  • All Free features
  • $100 starting limit (new users)
  • Level up to $500 limit
  • Bet Sync auto-tracks line movement
  • Filter bets by value
  • Full interactive historical data access
  • Profile badge

Pro+

  • Custom pricing
  • All Pro features
  • Pick your limit
  • Profile Badge
  • Requires a one-time refundable deposit
Screenshot of Pro+ pricing on BroThrow

How To Use BroThrow

Watch this quick overview of betting and settling payments on BroThrow.

Balance Sheet

The balance sheet is the best way to track your bets and payments on BroThrow. Your balance sheet is broken down by day. The easiest thing to do is let all of your bets for a day settle, and the following morning send and request any required payments.  The balance sheet tracks every bet you have with someone and gives you the net profit/loss.  For example, if you had two bets with the same person, the first won $35 and the second lost $20. The balance sheet would reflect that they owe you $10, reducing the required number of transactions and making tracking simpler.

You can quickly:

  • See the total number of bets as well as total profit/loss
  • See which individual bets won or lost
  • Track who you owe a payment to and how much
  • Track who owes you and how much
  • Request payments
  • Send payments
Screenshot of the BroThrow balance sheet

Notice the following:

  1. Summary of bets for the day.
  2. How much you stand to win or lose based on pending wagers.
  3. A losing wager where you owe Joseph D. $67.50.
  4. Pending wagers with Kaven N.
  5. $100 in winnings against Bart Y.

Clicking Settle Up shows you the payment providers you have in common with the other bettor and prepopulates the required username and payment amount for easy requests/payments.

Screenshot of the settle up screen on BroThrow

Is BroThrow Right For You

BroThrow might be good for you if:

  • You are looking for alternate methods to wager because you are limited on most sportsbooks.
  • You are looking for a smaller platform that tends to have soft lines.
  • You are willing to spend the time sending and requesting payments.
  • You want to request your own lines.

BroThrow might not be right for you if:

  • You do not want to spend the time requesting and sending payments.
  • You do not want to risk a user not paying you.
  • You do not want to be restricted to the set bet amounts requested by the other user.

More About Using BroThrow

Before signing up for BroThrow, DarkHorse Odds highly recommends watching their starter videos. They are a good introduction to how the platform works and what they offer.

Unique Terminology

  • Free Bet = Second Chance Bet, BroThrow reimburses you in the event of a loss.

Signup Offers

$10 Second Chance Bet

$10 Second Chance Bet Refunded as Site Credit

Amount: $10
Type: Second Chance Bet Refunded as Site Credit
Bet Finder: Second Chance Bet
Amount: $10
Type:
Bet Finder: Second Chance Bet
Deposit: $10
Minimum Hedge: $15
Expected Value: $7
Available in: Alabama, Alaska, Arizona, Arkansas, California, Connecticut, DC, Delaware, Florida, Georgia, Hawaii, Idaho, Illinois, Indiana, Iowa, Kentucky, Louisiana, Maine, Maryland, Massachusetts, Michigan, Minnesota, Mississippi, Missouri, Montana, Nebraska, Nevada, New Hampshire, New Jersey, New Mexico, New York, North Carolina, North Dakota, Ohio, Oklahoma, Oregon, Pennsylvania, Rhode Island, South Carolina, South Dakota, Tennessee, Texas, Utah, Vermont, Virginia, Washington, West Virginia, Wisconsin, Wyoming
No items found.

MLB House Rules

Each sportsbook has its own House Rules which determine how a bet is graded. These rules cover unlikely events, such as what happens to your bet when a game is canceled.

Usually, the different house rules across sportsbooks do not have an impact on matched betting. However, in Major League Baseball (MLB), there are notable exceptions. A simple example is when a game is postponed due to weather. Read our House Rules Comparison guide to learn more.

For MLB it is also important to understand what defines Action.

Money line

Will The Odds Change: No


Run / Total / Alt Lines

Action: Yes

Will The Odds Change: No


Player Props

Pitcher Prop action: Does Not Specify

Batter Prop action: Does Not Specify

Deposit & Withdraw Methods

No items found.
Share
© 2022 Dark Horse Odds. All right reserved.
Some of the links on DarkHorse Odds are affiliate links.

Gambling Problem?


Call 1-800-GAMBLER CO, DC, IL, KS, KY, LA, MD, MS, NJ, OH, PA, TN, VA, WV, WY , Call 877-8-HOPENY or text HOPENY (467369) (NY), Call 1-800-327-5050 (MA) 21+ to wager unless specified. Please gamble responsibly. Call 1-800-NEXT-STEP (AZ), 1-800-522-4700 (NV), Call 1-800-BETS-OFF (IA), 1-800-270-7117 for confidential help (MI), 1-800-981-0023 (PR). 19+. Gambling can be addictive. Please play responsibly (Ontario).